Peak Season
November 17, 2026

3 Ways Peak Season Costs You a Lifetime Customer

By
FRAYT

A dad finds the perfect gift for his teenage daughter who’s impossible to shop for, something that proves he really pays attention. He clicks “check out,” and the delivery date lands just in the nick of time. Then Christmas morning arrives, but those viral sneakers don't. He makes a mental note: never order from that retailer again, or at least not when it really matters.

Your customers don’t know who your last mile carrier is, and they don’t care what happened behind the scenes. When a delivery falls through, it’s your brand they remember, and your competitor who gets their next order.

During peak season, this problem compounds for retailers and e-commerce brands: people are shopping earlier, expecting faster deliveries, and watching shipping costs closely. Driver shortages are still a real issue in 2026, and fuel costs remain high. Through it all, your customers’ delivery experience will decide whether or not you get their repeat business. Here’s where it can go wrong.

1. Shoppers are buying before you’re ready.

Start with timing: shoppers aren’t waiting for December anymore. Among surveyed Walmart customers, over half will begin their shopping more than four weeks before the holidays this season, with another 20% starting three weeks out. That leaves you competing for holiday spending earlier than years past, and if you can’t promise a fast delivery while they’re still deciding, your competitor will end up as their go-to. Flip that outcome, and you could be the one they come back to.

2. Unpredictable shipping costs are driving carts away.

The good news is that consumers aren’t spending less (some reports even show a 5–6% increase in credit and debit card spending since last year); they’re just being choosier about where they spend their money. When every dollar counts, shipping costs matter, too. Who you choose for last mile delivery makes a real difference. Wasted cargo space, unnecessary fuel expenditure, and rigid routing all drive up costs. These inefficiencies turn into surcharges and invoices that fluctuate from month to month, forcing you to either absorb the cost in your margins or pass it on to shoppers through higher shipping fees. If you choose the latter, you may end up with a lot of abandoned carts.

3. Driver shortages put your delivery promises at risk.

Even if you find a partner with predictable delivery rates, there’s a bigger challenge heading into 2027: driver shortages. A shrinking driver pool is leaving many carriers high and dry and forcing them to raise pay to retain quality drivers. High driver turnover rates have left companies scrambling to get ahead of it, and peak season will only make it worse. When your carrier comes up short on drivers, your on-time, in-full (OTIF) rate is what slips. That dad doesn’t care why his gift showed up late. He just remembers the disappointment of not seeing his daughter's face light up on Christmas morning.

Turning Peak Season Into Repeat Business

None of these pressures are going away anytime soon, but they don’t have to cost you customers. What is potentially your biggest problem is also your biggest opportunity. Choosing a last mile partner that can deliver quickly with predictable, transparent pricing, and even help forecast your future needs, makes all the difference. With smart routing and a large driver pool, it can reliably fulfill its SLAs when you need it most. Your brand will be remembered as the one that came through in a pinch, and you’ll gain a customer for life. Here’s what that looks like in practice.

Plan capacity before peak, not during it

The smoothest peak season starts with a plan. The right partner should help you anticipate what lies ahead using your own data, not just react when volume spikes. Sherri Coffey, a Customer Success Manager at FRAYT, has spent years watching retailers and e-commerce brands scramble through the holiday rush, and she’s seen how much of the stress could be alleviated with planning. She describes how her team approaches it: “We use historical delivery trends alongside customers’ upcoming promotions, seasonal needs, and volume forecasts to help plan coverage.” Even the best forecast can’t predict everything. With the right partner alongside you that flexes with you when demand shifts unexpectedly, a surprise spike doesn't result in your OTIF plummeting.

Stop overpaying for wasted space

Look for a partner whose technology is built for efficiency, not just speed. Smart batching assesses demand across your full volume and groups orders into the routes most likely to meet your SLAs, in an appropriately sized vehicle, rather than dispatching each one in isolation. It’s a win-win: your deliveries arrive on time, and drivers get well-planned routes that make their time worth it, which keeps the best ones coming back. Some partners, FRAYT included, also offer Smart Batching, where your shipment is evaluated alongside others headed in the same direction, potentially giving you bulk pricing without the volume. Either way, you’re not paying for wasted space, fuel, or time.

Tap into a partner with a driver surplus

During a driver shortage, the size and quality of a partner’s network matter more than ever. Ask how drivers are vetted, how they’re supported, and why they stay. At FRAYT, a crowdsourced network of over 50,000 experienced drivers stay invested because they’re offered competitive wages, reliable lanes, and 24/7 support from network operators. They also have a highly rated driver’s app that gives shippers real-time visibility into every delivery. So while other carriers scramble for drivers, your deliveries stay on schedule.

This year, the coveted sneakers show up on time, and the dad doesn’t think twice about where he’s ordering from next Christmas, because he already knows.

Want to strategize your peak season? Secure time with our experts.